I am starting this post with a disclaimer that I have never been to a live concert ever in my life.. so far.. When I refer to a live concert, I meant the ones performed by the legends like Beegees, Eagles, Illayaraja and ARR(A.R.Rehman).. Now one may think why in the heavens name I am mentioning Beegees and Illayaraja in the same line.. Well, this whole post introspect the differences in the experience while watching the concerts of Beegess or Eagles Vs Illayaraja or ARR. My experience is purely through recorded concerts and I am a personal believer that I have a better experience while watching it on a DVD than in a live show.
Recently I had the first-in-my-life experience of watching Eagles perform live in Melbourne and ARR in Los Angeles. Before I start my introspection, I have to tell you how I came about experiencing the Eagles concert. Eagles is one of my favorite bands in the very few non-Indian music that I listen to.. So I have a DVR at home which I use quite often to record primetime shows. I have it pre-programmed to record during primetime from stations like NBC, CBS and ABC. During one such nights, NBC had aired this live concert of Eagles in their ER slot. So I guess you can now put 2 and 2 together... One of the very few times luck has been on my side and had come banging on my door.
As for the ARR show, I was in the public library the other day browsing for some Tamil movies, and happened to see this DVD of ARR giving a live concert in Los Angeles in 2000. So I picked it up to see how it was since, as you may know, that ARR gives very few live concerts. I will have to agree that this was one very elaborate concert with all the star playback singers like SPB, Hariharan, Shankar Maha.., Sujatha, Sadhana Sargam, Udit Nara... with Shivamani on the drums.. Now you can imagine what a wonderful lineup they had.. I was really impressed with the artists lineup...
Now comes the introspection... I saw the Eagles concert before I watched the ARR concert. The camera was just perfect, when the sax was playing, the saxophonist was the center stage, when the drum was rolling, drummer was in the limelight and when the Eagles were performing their magic on their guitars, you can guess where the camera was.. I can bet that I had a better experience of watching Eagles performing
Hotel California than the ones who were dancing to the tunes in the auditorium. The camera was just impeccably perfect. I make it a point to watch that song atleast once in week.. It used to be once every other day and it has now come down to once every week or 10 days..
Now comes ARR's concert. You have to give it to him... He had about 75 people in his orchestra and it was conducted superbly. But the camera was just horrible. Shivamani was stellar on the drums during the
Chandralekha song but he was nowhere to be seen on the TV screen. I was very disappointed. This was true for other orchestra members too. For one song, the sax was magical but I could only see green laser lights blinding my eyes.. The orchestra was doing a wonderful job but they were nowhere to be seen in the picture.. They have to take a lesson or two from the other concerts that are performed here. Its not just the singers that make a concert, its the whole nine yards that accompany them. Except for this technical glitch on the camera, the concert was simply superb. If you have not watched it, you should, atleast once..
The other concerts I have watched are of Beegees and Roy Orbison both with the same quality as Eagles... I love watching concerts on TV.. Never tried it live, so do not want to be too critical about it..
Whew.. Its been quite a while since I had written such a long one..